29 Jan 2024

Daily practice questions for CLAT - (29 Jan 2024)



In order to protect the rights of women employees during pregnancy and after childbirth, Indian law makes it mandatory for most establishments to offer maternity benefits to women employees. Maternity benefit in India is mainly governed by the Maternity Benefit Act, 1961 that applies to all shops and establishments with 10 or more employees. Remember that employers are required to inform women in writing and electronically about the maternity benefits available under the Maternity Benefit Act upon their joining the workforce. The Maternity Benefit Act (MBA) provides that a woman will be paid maternity benefit at the rate of her average daily wage in the three months preceding her maternity leave. However, the woman needs to have worked for the employer for at least 80 days in the 12 months preceding the date of her expected delivery. The Maternity Benefit Act originally provided maternity benefit of 12 weeks, out of which up to six weeks could be claimed before delivery. In 2017, the law was amended to extend the period to 26 weeks. Out of the 26 weeks, up to a maximum of eight weeks can be claimed before delivery. One can even take the entire 26 weeks of leave after the delivery. Also, these are maximum periods of claim and you can claim the benefit for a smaller period as well. The law was also amended to extend maternity benefits to commissioning and adoptive mothers who are now entitled to 12 weeks of leave from the date the mother receives the child. Women undergoing a tubectomy operation (a medical procedure to stop future pregnancies) also get a paid leave of two weeks following the operation. In case of miscarriage or medical termination of pregnancy, the law permits women six weeks’ leave after the procedure. In case of an illness after delivery, miscarriage, medical termination of pregnancy or tubectomy, a woman can claim a leave with wages for a further period of one month, over and above what is allowed. The law also allows employers to permit women employees to work from home in addition to the maternity benefit period if the nature of work allows that. The law was further amended in 2017 to make it mandatory for establishments with more than 50 workers to establish crèches. Mothers are entitled to visit the crèches up to four times a day and to two nursing breaks per day in addition to any other breaks that are available as a matter of course, until the child attains the age of 15 months.

Question1:- Mrs. Yashika is working in an MNC having a staff of over 500 employees. She has a four months baby at home. She is thinking of quitting her job as she is not able to properly nurse her baby. Based on the passage, what legal advice would you offer her?
  • A. She cannot quit as she has already delivered the baby.
  • B. She should quit after claiming 6 months’ salary under the Maternity Benefit Act.
  • C. She can request her company to provide a crèche where she can nurse her baby.
  • D. She must quit as human life is more precious than money.
Answer is C is correct. She can request her company to provide a crèche where she can nurse her baby. In the last paragraph, it is mentioned that any establishment with over 50 employees has to provide a crèche in the office where a mother may nurse her baby upto 15 months of age (… make it mandatory for establishments with more than 50 workers to establish crèches. Mothers are entitled to visit the crèches up to four times a day and to two nursing breaks per day in addition to any other breaks that are available as a matter of course, until the child attains the age of 15 months). Her child is 4 months old and her company has over 500 employees. Hence, she can claim the benefits under the mentioned provision. Options (B) and (D) do not address her concern which is to strike a balance between her job and baby. Option (A) is incorrect as no such bar on quitting a job is mentioned in the passage. Hence, C is the correct option.
Question2:- Mrs. X delivered her first baby. A year later she and her husband decide to have only one child seeing the population explosion in India and the ramification it would have on future generations. They accordingly go for a tubectomy operation. Decide.
  • A. Mrs. X can claim 2 weeks paid leave from office.
  • B. Mrs. X can claim 26 weeks of paid leave.
  • C. Mrs. X can get paid leave only if she is in government service.
  • D. Mrs. X will not get any paid leave.
Answer is A is correct. : Mrs. X can claim 2 weeks paid leave from office. A woman who undergoes tubectomy is entitled to a maximum of 2 weeks paid leave as mentioned in the 3rd paragraph (Women undergoing a tubectomy operation, a medical procedure to stop future pregnancies, also get a paid leave of two weeks following the operation). Option (D) is therefore, incorrect. Option (B) is incorrect as 26 weeks paid leave is given during childbirth. Option (C) is incorrect as no such distinction between government and private service is mentioned in the passage. Hence, A is the correct option.
Question3:- Mrs. Avantika joined the firm in January, 2021. In Feb, 2022 she got pregnant. She worked in the office for the next 3 months and claimed 6 months paid leave. Choose the most appropriate option.
  • A. Mrs. Avantika cannot claim the paid leave in the manner as aforementioned.
  • B. Mrs. Avantika cannot claim the paid leave as she intentionally got pregnant to get paid leave.
  • C. Mrs. Avantika can get the claimed paid leave for 6 months.
  • D. Mrs. Avantika can get paid leave for upto 2 week before delivery.
Answer is B is correct. Mrs. Avantika cannot claim the paid leave in the manner as aforementioned. In the 2nd paragraph, the correct manner of arrangement of 26 weeks of paid leave under MBA is mentioned (Out of the 26 weeks, up to a maximum of 8 weeks can be claimed before delivery). The maximum limit of paid leave before delivery is 8 weeks or roughly 2 months. In the instant case Mrs. Avantika applied for 6 months paid leave before delivery. This is not the correct manner though she may claim this 6-months paid leave after delivery. Option (C) is therefore incorrect. Option (B) is out of context. Option (D) is incorrect as she can claim upto 8 weeks of paid leave before delivery. Hence, A is the correct option.
Question4:- Below, you have been supplied with four options. Suppose Lakshmi wants to make her boss aware about this bill. What is the point which she will not make before her boss?
  • A. Even adoptive mothers can get some benefits under the Maternity Benefits Act.
  • B. Even the husbands of pregnant ladies could get certain benefits under the Maternity Benefits Act.
  • C. A pregnant woman may claim additional paid leave following illness post-delivery.
  • D. Pregnant women may be allowed to work from home in certain cases.
Answer is B is correct. Even the husbands of pregnant ladies could get certain benefits under the Maternity Benefits Act. Nowhere in the entire passage, are benefits to the husband of the pregnant lady mentioned. Option (B) therefore, cannot be derived from the passage. Adoptive mothers can claim benefits under the MBA as mentioned in the third paragraph (The law was also amended to extend maternity benefits to commissioning and adoptive mothers who are now entitled to 12 weeks of leave from the date the mother receives the child). Option (A) is therefore, correct. Option (C) is also correct as such provision is mentioned in the 3rd paragraph (In case of an illness after delivery…a woman can claim a leave with wages for a further period of one month, over and above what is allowed). Option (D) is correct as work from home is provided under the MBA. Refer to the last paragraph (The law also allows employers to permit women employees to work from home in addition to the maternity benefit period if the nature of work allows that). Hence, B is the correct option.